Demotion for Making Students Eat on Floor Held Not to Violate Pact
 |
| PS 34 protest against Nancy Miller |
New York Law Journal
02-21-2012
Cite as: Miller v. Theodore-Tassy, 7593/08, NYLJ 1202542558456, at *1 (App. Div., 2nd, Decided February 7, 2012)A former assistant vice principal who was demoted after she allegedly forced 13 bilingual students to eat on the floor with their hands has been rebuffed in her attempt to sue the teacher who reported the discipline to school officials.
A unanimous panel of the Appellate Division, Second Department, dismissed a claim of tortious interference with a contract filed by former assistant principal Nancy Miller against teacher Margaret Theodore-Tassy.
Ms. Theordore-Tassy made a prima facie showing that the New York City's Department of Education "did not breach a contract of employment" with Ms. Miller when Ms. Miller was discontinued from her probationary assistant principal's position, the court ruled on Feb. 7 in Miller v. Theodore-Tassy, 2010-10119.
Moreover, the Second Department found that Ms. Miller had failed to raise a triable issue of fact as to whether the education department breached a contract with her following the March 2005 incident, which attracted widespread negative publicity.
In dismissing the suit, the unanimous panel reversed a decision by Queens Supreme Court Justice Kevin J. Kerrigan (See Profile) that had permitted Ms. Miller's action against Ms. Theodore-Tassy to proceed.
Ms. Miller was on lunch duty at P.S. 34 in Queens when she apparently decided that Ms. Theodore-Tassy's Haitian students were misbehaving. According to the account that the teacher gave to school authorities and the subsequent investigation, Ms. Miller disciplined the students by forcing them to eat on the floor without utensils.
Ms. Theodore-Tassy later asked her students to write statements describing what happened, letters that were reviewed during the investigation by the Board of Education's Office of Special Investigations.
Following a hearing, Ms. Miller was found guilty of forcing the students to eat on the floor, not allowing them to use utensils, and bringing widespread negative publicity to the department, but she was found not guilty of calling them "animals" and making disparaging remarks about their country of origin. She was fined $10,000 and returned to her job as a teacher.
In April 2006, Ms. Miller filed a defamation action against Ms. Theodore-Tassy, school officials, the other teacher, the parent, and news media outlets. The claims all were thrown out. Ms. Miller then sued Ms. Theodore-Tassy, another teacher and a parent for tortious interference.
Her complaint claimed that Ms. Theodore-Tassy helped her students write false accounts of the incident, including unsubstantiated allegations that the vice principal told the children that "in Haiti they treat you like animals, and I treat you the same way here."
She also charged that the teacher, with the help of the codefendants, disseminated the students' letters to the New York Daily News and other media outlets.
Ms. Miller claimed Ms. Theodore-Tassy harbored a "deep and abiding contempt, distrust and dislike" for her and tried to destroy the vice principal's reputation out of fear of losing her job because enrollment was declining in the bilingual program.
Ms. Theodore-Tassy's actions, she said, interfered both with a collective bargaining agreement and a purported oral contract Ms. Miller had with P.S. 34 principal Pauline Shakespeare.
On Aug. 30, 2010, Justice Kerrigan denied Ms. Theodore-Tassy's motion for summary judgment, finding that Ms. Miller's complaint satisfied the elements for a tortious interference claim: the existence of a contract, a showing that the defendant knew about the agreement and that she intentionally induced the city to breach it, damaging Ms. Miller.
Justice Kerrigan questioned whether Ms. Theodore-Tassy's alleged actions, especially claims that she contacted the press, were within the scope of her duties as a teacher.
Moreover, the judge noted that Ms. Theodore-Tassy could not prove that either the collective bargaining agreement or oral contract did not exist.
On appeal, the city argued that Ms. Miller did not identify any specific contract provision of the principals' agreement that the education department had violated.
It also noted that Ms. Miller had not asserted the existence of an oral contract in her complaint, only mentioning it during a deposition. In any case, the city said that the claim was "inherently incredible and is flatly contradicted by documentary evidence."
The Second Department accepted the city's argument in an unsigned opinion joined by Justices Mark C. Dillon (See Profile), John M. Leventhal (See Profile), Ariel E. Belen (See Profile) and Plummer E. Lott (See Profile). The panel heard oral arguments on Jan. 17.
"We are pleased with the decision and believe that the demotion and fine were an appropriate disciplinary action," Tahirih Sadrieh, senior counsel at the New York City Law Department, said in a statement.
Marshall B. Bellovin of Ballon Stoll Bader & Nadler in Manhattan, who represents Ms. Miller, said that his client is considering an appeal.
"We agree with the trial court that the defendant failed to meet her burden and she failed to show that the oral and written contracts did not exist," Mr. Bellovin said in an interview.
He added that the teacher did not offer evidence contradicting Ms. Miller's claim that she told the students to write letters making false statements and instructed the other teacher to contact the media.
Rudy A. Dermesropian also advised Ms. Miller.
@|Laura Haring can be contacted at lharing@alm.com
ATTORNEYS
For Respondent: Ballon Stoll Bader & Nadler, P.C., New York, N.Y. (Marshall B. Bellovin and Rudy A. Dermesropian of counsel).
For Appellant: Michael A. Cardozo, Corporation Counsel, New York, N.Y. (Edward F. X. Hart and Tahirih M. Sadrieh of counsel).
DECISION & ORDER
In an action to recover damages for tortious interference with contract, the defendant Margaret Theodore-Tassy appeals from an order of the Supreme Court, Queens County (Kerrigan, J.), entered August 30, 2010, which denied her motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint insofar as asserted against her or for leave to amend her answer to add certain affirmative defenses.
ORDERED that the order is reversed, on the law, with costs, that branch of the motion of the defendant Margaret Theodore-Tassy which was for summary judgment dismissing the complaint insofar as asserted against her is granted, and the motion is otherwise denied as academic.
In 2004 the plaintiff, a tenured teacher, was appointed as a probationary assistant principal at an elementary school in Queens by the school's principal, who acted pursuant to authority delegated to her by the Chancellor of the City of New York Department of Education (hereinafter the DOE). In March 2005, an investigation was initiated after allegations arose that the plaintiff, while supervising lunch in the cafeteria, disciplined a class of students taught by the defendant Margarette Tassy, sued herein as Margaret Theodore-Tassy, by forcing the students to eat their lunch on the floor, not allowing them to retrieve utensils and thereby forcing them to eat with their hands, referring to them as "animals," and making disparaging remarks about their country of origin. The allegations garnered considerable press coverage.
Following the investigation, the allegations that the plaintiff forced the students to eat lunch on the floor without utensils and referred to them as animals were substantiated, but the allegation that she made disparaging remarks about their country of origin was not substantiated. Thereafter, the plaintiff was discontinued as a probationary assistant principal, and the DOE preferred charges against her pursuant to Education Law §3020-a. Following a hearing, the plaintiff was found guilty of forcing the students to eat lunch onthe floor, not allowing them to retrieve utensils, and causing widespread negative publicity to the DOE by these actions, but she was found not guilty of referring to the students as animals. The hearing officer imposed a fine of $10,000, and the plaintiff resumed duties as a teacher.
The plaintiff commenced this action against, among others, Tassy to recover damages for tortious interference with contract, citing a contract of employment between her and the DOE whereby she was appointed to be a probationary assistant principal. The plaintiff alleged, inter alia, that Tassy instructed her students to write fabricated accounts of the cafeteria incident in which they accused the plaintiff of making derogatory remarks to them, helped the students write the accounts, reported the fabricated incident to school officials, and, in concert with others, disseminated the fabricated incident to the press, actions which procured a breach of her employment contract with the DOE. In the order appealed from, the Supreme Court, among other things, denied that branch of Tassy's motion which was for summary judgment dismissing the complaint insofar as asserted against her.
To prevail on a cause of action alleging tortious interference with contract, a plaintiff must establish "the existence of a valid contract between the plaintiff and a third party, defendant's knowledge of that contract, defendant's intentional procurement of the third-party's breach of the contract without justification, actual breach of the contract, and damages resulting therefrom" (Lama Holding Co. v. Smith Barney, 88 NY2d 413, 424; see NBT Bancorp v. Fleet/Norstar Fin. Group, 87 NY2d 614, 620-621; Monex Fin. Servs., Ltd. v. Dynamic Currency Conversion, Inc., 76 AD3d 515). Here, Tassy made a prima facie showing of her entitlement to judgment as a matter of law by submitting evidence demonstrating that the DOE did not breach a contract of employment with the plaintiff when she was discontinued from her probationary assistant principal position. In opposition, the plaintiff failed to raise a triable issue of fact as to whether the DOE breached an employment contract with her (see Alvarez v. Prospect Hosp., 68 NY2d 320, 324). Accordingly, the Supreme Court should have granted that branch of Tassy's motion which was for summary judgment dismissing the complaint insofar as asserted against her.
In light of our determination, Tassy's remaining contentions have been rendered academic.
DILLON, J.P., LEVENTHAL, BELEN and LOTT, JJ., concur.
From Betsy Combier: The following post is not mine, I am re-posting it from the Internet because of the anger and frustration that Nancy Miller's action caused..
JG weighs in on the Abuse of Haitian kids at PS 34
*********************
counterpunch
http://www.counterpunch.org/
April 13, 2005
*********************
counterpunch
http://www.counterpunch.org/
April 13, 2005
"They Will Treat You Like Animals"
The Abuse of Haitian Kids at PS 34
By J.G.
Los Angeles, Cali.
savage (noun)
1. vicious or violent person somebody who enjoys treating other
people and animals in a cruel and violent way
2. offensive term an offensive term for a member of a people
considered inferior or not as advanced as your own group
Peace to Encarta the Linguists across North America thank you.
Either the administrators of New York City's Public School 34 aren't hip to semantics, or their most recent interpretation and application of the term "savage" is entirely incongruent to the discourse of White-patriarchal-privilege, and most specifically here, the hastening assault against the Haitian Global Community by a myriad selection of American society. For further elaboration, please see the following.
As a seasoned and rather proud cynic, there are few displays of barbarism that tweak the nerves, bring about a spat of fury, a vitriolic spasm, and what have you. Forget that last bit of deceit. In reality, all too often, I do succumb to the sexy red temptress of rage. The latest chapter of rancor and virulence proliferated by New York Public School 34's Assistant Principle Nancy Miller and Principle Pauline Shakespeare has my bowels in fits.
"While all my city is heavy I drop elephant shit
Smeared the face of the fascist priest's pulpit"
______________Zach De La Rocha
Yup.
New York's cultural cabal stays heavy, dropping fecal matter from the fuselage of pig despotism, late-night blackface, mayoral-Mussolinism and the like; Stuka war eagles razing the Black, Brown and Migrant communities like the Ho Chi Minh trail. For the Haitian Community, Operation Phoenix leapt through McNamara's porthole of kill-tha-gook and embedded itself within the psyche of city-commandants. 'Nou tout Viet Cong' We are all Viet Cong. Savages, in short.
Thirteen fourth grade students on public trial. The jury PS34 populace. The courtroom school cafeteria. The crime being Haitian.
In response to a classroom conflict involving two students, educational hack Nancy Miller, as white-cloaked-judge in de facto robe, sentenced the youths to public humiliation and ethnic degradation. As punishment for acting in the universal vein of childhood, she sat the children on the cafeteria floor before the student-jury, forced them to eat their lunch of rice and chicken with bare hands, subjecting them to a primary-educational-stoning, equipped with demeaning glances and ridicule per their peers.
According to the "guilty" parties, Miller's articulation was as such: "In Haiti, they treat you like animals, and I will treat you the same way here." Yes Ms. Miller, in Haiti, they, 'Blancs yo' (Whites / foreigners / outsiders, aka UN, U$, France, Canada, USAID, OAS, CIA, 184, Haitian Elite) do treat us as inferior peoples, acting as only savages can. We expect no less from you, you studious apprentice. Only through the lens of a dysfunctional clique of negrophobes could such a valiant people be "considered inferior." If time travel were possible, now would be an excellent time to send message to General Le Clerc and Napoleon Bonaparte. The query: How humiliating was the serving, guerilla style in 1804?
The plot thickens. Principle Pauline Shakespeare, a sister no less- pause for dramatic effect - a 'fucking' sister exemplified the role of house-hand, Sanbo, McWhorter, Watts, Powell, Condoskeeza, Cosby, Blackwell; attempted a cover up, in doing so, efforting to bribe the gesticulating "savages," rather "animals," with ice cream.
Shit, you know tha ghetto's got sweet teeth. Miller and Shakespeare promoted the stereotype to the wrong community. In Haiti, we sharpen sugar cane stalks to pierce United Nations APV's.
Mucho Kudos to Juan Gonzalez of the 'New York Daily News' for breaking a story, previously solely known to the listener ship of New York and East Coast Haitian Radio. I'll go on the offensive here.
Those who are morally outraged and shocked require a crash-course in Jim Crow history. For extra credit, do rent Jerry Bruckheimer's amateurish, over-budgeted, over-hyped, vituperative, virulent Hollywood concoction, Bad Boys II, from your neighborhood dope dealer (Hollyhood Video the pointy cap, sorcerer type of hood of "lynch a nigga by his toe", as opposed to "Boys in tha Hood"). Will Smith's gloves are as white as bleach, lips as red as Porsche during the many scenes in which Haitian's are demeaned, vilified, dehumanized and slandered with a belligerence not bettered by Jesse Helms. Or, find a copy of Rockstar's video-gaming filth, Vice City.
Deconstruct the argumentation of genocide: "I hate those Haitians. We'll take them out, we'll take these Haitians down," uncannily similar logic permeating the above shoot-em-up pornography (that's how Bruckheimer does it, PS2's fo real!). Arsenio and Whoopi cooning to Middle America circa 1990's with limericks about AIDS and Haitians; Abner Louima, toilet plunger, need I say more? And the savages are? That the latest colonization, pillage and genocide of the Haitian People (presidential kidnapping and coup d'etat, February 29th 2004, 10,000+ murdered since, countless internally and externally exiled, Apartheid on the rise) be ample ammunition to spark the carbines of dissent is understood. Yeah, the PS34 investigation ensues, bureaucratic double-speak tight-lipped replies to independent media intrigues. This drama was authored centuries past by an ancestor by way of slave-ownership of school Principal Ms. Pauline, The Shakespeare, William precisely. Moral outrage is the director's cue.
Appealing to the collective conscience of that class history has proven have none, is no more than propagating a lineage of perfunctory reforms increasingly insulting to the victims of injustice. 'Revolution or Reform? Revolution in the Revolution'? My
peoples Rosa and Regis, where tha hell you at?
*
JG is of the best-known and most recognizable Independent Hip Hop artists nationally. His music deals exclusively with the plight of disenfranchised communities, most specifically, that of the Haitian Global Village. His most recent release, Boomerang Politick, which protests the most recent occupation of Haiti, is available for purchase at his website: www.insurgentjg.com and at IMIX Bookstore in Los Angeles California.
The Abuse of Haitian Kids at PS 34
By J.G.
Los Angeles, Cali.
savage (noun)
1. vicious or violent person somebody who enjoys treating other
people and animals in a cruel and violent way
2. offensive term an offensive term for a member of a people
considered inferior or not as advanced as your own group
Peace to Encarta the Linguists across North America thank you.
Either the administrators of New York City's Public School 34 aren't hip to semantics, or their most recent interpretation and application of the term "savage" is entirely incongruent to the discourse of White-patriarchal-privilege, and most specifically here, the hastening assault against the Haitian Global Community by a myriad selection of American society. For further elaboration, please see the following.
As a seasoned and rather proud cynic, there are few displays of barbarism that tweak the nerves, bring about a spat of fury, a vitriolic spasm, and what have you. Forget that last bit of deceit. In reality, all too often, I do succumb to the sexy red temptress of rage. The latest chapter of rancor and virulence proliferated by New York Public School 34's Assistant Principle Nancy Miller and Principle Pauline Shakespeare has my bowels in fits.
"While all my city is heavy I drop elephant shit
Smeared the face of the fascist priest's pulpit"
______________Zach De La Rocha
Yup.
New York's cultural cabal stays heavy, dropping fecal matter from the fuselage of pig despotism, late-night blackface, mayoral-Mussolinism and the like; Stuka war eagles razing the Black, Brown and Migrant communities like the Ho Chi Minh trail. For the Haitian Community, Operation Phoenix leapt through McNamara's porthole of kill-tha-gook and embedded itself within the psyche of city-commandants. 'Nou tout Viet Cong' We are all Viet Cong. Savages, in short.
Thirteen fourth grade students on public trial. The jury PS34 populace. The courtroom school cafeteria. The crime being Haitian.
In response to a classroom conflict involving two students, educational hack Nancy Miller, as white-cloaked-judge in de facto robe, sentenced the youths to public humiliation and ethnic degradation. As punishment for acting in the universal vein of childhood, she sat the children on the cafeteria floor before the student-jury, forced them to eat their lunch of rice and chicken with bare hands, subjecting them to a primary-educational-stoning, equipped with demeaning glances and ridicule per their peers.
According to the "guilty" parties, Miller's articulation was as such: "In Haiti, they treat you like animals, and I will treat you the same way here." Yes Ms. Miller, in Haiti, they, 'Blancs yo' (Whites / foreigners / outsiders, aka UN, U$, France, Canada, USAID, OAS, CIA, 184, Haitian Elite) do treat us as inferior peoples, acting as only savages can. We expect no less from you, you studious apprentice. Only through the lens of a dysfunctional clique of negrophobes could such a valiant people be "considered inferior." If time travel were possible, now would be an excellent time to send message to General Le Clerc and Napoleon Bonaparte. The query: How humiliating was the serving, guerilla style in 1804?
The plot thickens. Principle Pauline Shakespeare, a sister no less- pause for dramatic effect - a 'fucking' sister exemplified the role of house-hand, Sanbo, McWhorter, Watts, Powell, Condoskeeza, Cosby, Blackwell; attempted a cover up, in doing so, efforting to bribe the gesticulating "savages," rather "animals," with ice cream.
Shit, you know tha ghetto's got sweet teeth. Miller and Shakespeare promoted the stereotype to the wrong community. In Haiti, we sharpen sugar cane stalks to pierce United Nations APV's.
Mucho Kudos to Juan Gonzalez of the 'New York Daily News' for breaking a story, previously solely known to the listener ship of New York and East Coast Haitian Radio. I'll go on the offensive here.
Those who are morally outraged and shocked require a crash-course in Jim Crow history. For extra credit, do rent Jerry Bruckheimer's amateurish, over-budgeted, over-hyped, vituperative, virulent Hollywood concoction, Bad Boys II, from your neighborhood dope dealer (Hollyhood Video the pointy cap, sorcerer type of hood of "lynch a nigga by his toe", as opposed to "Boys in tha Hood"). Will Smith's gloves are as white as bleach, lips as red as Porsche during the many scenes in which Haitian's are demeaned, vilified, dehumanized and slandered with a belligerence not bettered by Jesse Helms. Or, find a copy of Rockstar's video-gaming filth, Vice City.
Deconstruct the argumentation of genocide: "I hate those Haitians. We'll take them out, we'll take these Haitians down," uncannily similar logic permeating the above shoot-em-up pornography (that's how Bruckheimer does it, PS2's fo real!). Arsenio and Whoopi cooning to Middle America circa 1990's with limericks about AIDS and Haitians; Abner Louima, toilet plunger, need I say more? And the savages are? That the latest colonization, pillage and genocide of the Haitian People (presidential kidnapping and coup d'etat, February 29th 2004, 10,000+ murdered since, countless internally and externally exiled, Apartheid on the rise) be ample ammunition to spark the carbines of dissent is understood. Yeah, the PS34 investigation ensues, bureaucratic double-speak tight-lipped replies to independent media intrigues. This drama was authored centuries past by an ancestor by way of slave-ownership of school Principal Ms. Pauline, The Shakespeare, William precisely. Moral outrage is the director's cue.
Appealing to the collective conscience of that class history has proven have none, is no more than propagating a lineage of perfunctory reforms increasingly insulting to the victims of injustice. 'Revolution or Reform? Revolution in the Revolution'? My
peoples Rosa and Regis, where tha hell you at?
*
JG is of the best-known and most recognizable Independent Hip Hop artists nationally. His music deals exclusively with the plight of disenfranchised communities, most specifically, that of the Haitian Global Village. His most recent release, Boomerang Politick, which protests the most recent occupation of Haiti, is available for purchase at his website: www.insurgentjg.com and at IMIX Bookstore in Los Angeles California.
*******
PROTEST THE ABUSE AT P.S. 34
THE HAITIAN COMMUNITY SAYS:
NO TO RACISM!
NO TO DISCRIMINATION!
NO TO THE DENIGRATION OF OUR CHILDREN IN THEIR OWN SCHOOLS!
CALL, WRITE, E-MAIL, & FAX:
Chancellor Joel Klein: Tel: 212-374-0200, Fax: 212 374 5588,
Email: chancellor@nycboe.net
Regional Superintendent Judith Chin: Tel: 718-281-7528, Email:
JChin@nycboe.net and LOjeda@nycboe.net
CALL:
* Robert Small - Head of Special Investigation into this PS-34 abuse case
* Jennifer Graham - Head of the Response Team for Chancellor Joel Klein on this PS-34 matter at 212-374-5156
* Local Instructional Superintendent Janet Won at 718-281-3407, and
* PS-34 at 718 465 6818
CALL:
Your local congressional representative in New York, the media and the mayor’s office to spread the word and fax this sheet to all Press contacts.
The Haitian community will not tolerate human rights abuses in the U.S.
We have suffered ENOUGH!!! Our children will be vindicated only with a full and public apology, the firing of both Miller and Shakespeare and the school providing counseling and trauma care to these 8 and 9 year old innocents.
For more Information:
Call 718-464-6068 or email: janpetro@aol.com
COMMITTEE FOR JUSTICE FOR THE 13 HAITIAN CHILDREN AT PS-34
April 12, 2005
*********************
Forwarded by the Haitian Lawyers' Leadership Network
Email: chancellor@nycboe.net
Regional Superintendent Judith Chin: Tel: 718-281-7528, Email:
JChin@nycboe.net and LOjeda@nycboe.net
CALL:
* Robert Small - Head of Special Investigation into this PS-34 abuse case
* Jennifer Graham - Head of the Response Team for Chancellor Joel Klein on this PS-34 matter at 212-374-5156
* Local Instructional Superintendent Janet Won at 718-281-3407, and
* PS-34 at 718 465 6818
CALL:
Your local congressional representative in New York, the media and the mayor’s office to spread the word and fax this sheet to all Press contacts.
The Haitian community will not tolerate human rights abuses in the U.S.
We have suffered ENOUGH!!! Our children will be vindicated only with a full and public apology, the firing of both Miller and Shakespeare and the school providing counseling and trauma care to these 8 and 9 year old innocents.
For more Information:
Call 718-464-6068 or email: janpetro@aol.com
COMMITTEE FOR JUSTICE FOR THE 13 HAITIAN CHILDREN AT PS-34
April 12, 2005
*********************
Forwarded by the Haitian Lawyers' Leadership Network
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar